Question 1

How should I evaluate a Canadian SEO agency?

Accepted Answer

Evaluation criteria: 1) Senior-practitioner involvement (will the strategist who pitches you also work on your account?). 2) Published examples of their thinking (case studies, playbooks, written work). 3) Editorial honesty (do they discuss what doesn't work, not just success stories?). 4) Pricing transparency (flat-rate retainer over performance-based or vague 'custom' pricing). 5) References from current clients in similar verticals. 6) AODA / accessibility awareness for Canadian regulatory compliance.

Question 2

What are red flags when evaluating an SEO agency?

Accepted Answer

Red flags: guaranteed rankings, performance-based / pay-per-ranking pricing, no published case studies or evidence of work, junior account managers running engagements (with senior practitioners only on the sales call), opaque link-building practices, claims of 'secret' Google relationships, requests for excessive scope creep without scope-change billing, refusal to discuss what didn't work in past engagements.

Question 3

Should I hire a Toronto-local SEO agency or any agency in Canada?

Accepted Answer

For local SEO (Map Pack, GBP, Toronto-specific intent), local Toronto presence helps — local agencies understand neighbourhood-level competitive dynamics and Canadian regulatory context (AODA, Bill 96, CASL). For national / international SEO programs, geographic location matters less than practitioner quality. Most modern Canadian SEO engagements run remotely; in-person visits are occasional rather than weekly. Choose for skill match, not geography.

Question 4

How many SEO agencies should I shortlist before deciding?

Accepted Answer

3-5 is usually right. More than 5 dilutes evaluation depth; fewer than 3 risks not having a meaningful comparison set. The shortlist should span price tiers (one solo / boutique, two mid-market specialists, one premium) to surface what each tier actually delivers for the price. Use the same scoping document across all shortlisted vendors so proposals are comparable.

Question 5

What questions should I ask in an SEO vendor sales call?

Accepted Answer

Ask for: 1) A specific case-study walk-through in your vertical with metrics. 2) Who specifically will run your account day-to-day (and can you meet them?). 3) Their last 3 client losses or churn — and why. 4) How they measure AEO / AI engine citations. 5) Their approach to a recent Google core update. 6) Their position on AI-generated content. 7) Their typical 90-day deliverable list. Vague answers to these questions reveal weaker practices.

Comparing SEO Vendors

Other FAQ categories

Have a different question?