Why topical authority is real
Google has not published a "topical authority score," but the ranking behaviour is unmistakable. On competitive queries, Google consistently surfaces results from sites whose entire footprint signals expertise on the topic — even when individual pages on those sites are not the best-optimized for the specific query. A new article on a niche-authority site routinely outranks a more-optimized article on a generalist site.
The structural read is that the ranking system uses some combination of query-cluster coverage, semantic relatedness signals, internal-linking patterns, and authorship signals to estimate domain-level expertise on a topic. Pages on high-expertise domains get a ranking boost; pages on low-expertise-for-the-topic domains get a corresponding suppression.